A tragedy that unfolded in Medford , Oregon hospital, has taken center stage as families of deceased and infected patients sue Asante Rogue Regional Medical Center for negligence. The lawsuit alleges a chilling sequence of events where intravenous (IV) drips, meant to deliver fentanyl, were instead filled with tap water. This swap resulted in bacterial infections affecting over 40 patients, 16 of whom lost their lives.
What Happened at Asante Rogue Regional Medical Center?
The lawsuit claims that former nurse Dani Marie Schofield “swapped tap water for liquid fentanyl meant for dozens of patients in the intensive care unit.” According to investigators, Schofield used the powerful opioid herself, leaving patients vulnerable to bacterial infections. Arrested in June, Schofield faces 44 counts of second-degree assault and has pleaded not guilty. While not named as a defendant in this particular lawsuit, her alleged actions are central to the accusations of institutional negligence.
Families and estates of nine deceased patients, along with nine others who suffered infections, are plaintiffs in the $303 million wrongful death and medical malpractice lawsuit. According to court documents, the hospital “failed to detect the theft” and allowed “unreasonable levels of bacteria” in its water supply, leading to the devastating outcomes.
The Devastating Toll of Bacterial Infections
Between July 2022 and July 2023, more than 40 patients developed bacterial infections after receiving IV drips laced with tap water instead of fentanyl. These infections were “uniquely associated with waterborne transmission,” according to the lawsuit. Among those who died were a cannabis grower recovering from a fall, a retiree suffering from a bed sore, and a military veteran receiving treatment for liver failure. The veteran’s family told local media that he had a “good prognosis” before this catastrophic intervention.
Despite the deaths, Schofield has not been charged with murder or manslaughter. Authorities explained that they could not definitively prove the infections directly caused the deaths, highlighting the legal complexities of medical malpractice cases.
Also Read: Organic eggs sold under Costco Kirkland label recalled for salmonella risk
Institutional Oversight and the Nationwide Epidemic of Drug Diversion
The lawsuit accuses Asante Rogue Regional Medical Center of failing to monitor its employees despite “repeated instances of drug misuse by its employees in the past.” The issue of drug diversion, where medical professionals steal prescription drugs for personal use, is not new. Similar cases have been reported nationwide, including a paramedic in Colorado and a fertility clinic nurse in Connecticut, both of whom misused fentanyl intended for patients.
The Medford Police Department launched an investigation after the hospital reported a spike in infections. The complaint alleges that hospital administrators knew of drug diversion concerns yet failed to implement adequate monitoring and safeguards.
Legal Consequences and Broader Implications
If convicted, Schofield could face up to 70 months in prison for each assault charge. Meanwhile, the plaintiffs seek justice for the “mental anguish, medical expenses, lost income, and pain and suffering” caused by this tragedy. At least one additional lawsuit has been filed against the hospital and Schofield, underscoring the far-reaching consequences of institutional lapses in safety protocols.
This case has also reignited discussions about the vulnerabilities in healthcare systems. Experts stress the need for better monitoring of painkiller administration and stronger support systems for medical professionals struggling with addiction.